| Name | Sacrifices | Career |
| Sam Seeger | 13 | 91-93 |
| Lance Lamberth | 12 | 95-98 |
| Sam Cooke | 12 | 00-02 |
| Brian Krug | 12 | 91-93 |
| Anthony Rhodes | 11 | 02-04 |
| Michael Castleberry | 10 | 96-98 |
| Patrick Smith | 10 | 02-04 |
| Kip Platt | 10 | 90-92 |
| Weldon Davis | 10 | 02-04 |
| Jason Gist | 10 | 93-96 |
| Ross Mattox | 9 | 93-96 |
| Chad LaRose | 9 | 93-96 |
| John Wackerly | 9 | 97-00 |
| Kyler Pomeroy | 8 | 97-99 |
| Jeremy Burba | 8 | 02-04 |